Scholes believes that Fernandes' versatility is both a strength and a weakness. While he has been instrumental in carrying the team on his back, his ability to play in multiple positions can also cause confusion in the team's system. Scholes thinks that Fernandes' value lies in his ability to score goals and create chances, but he struggles to find a fixed position in the team.

Carragher agrees with Scholes, describing Fernandes as a "great talent" but not a "great player". He points out that Fernandes often runs wildly around the pitch, which can be both impressive and chaotic. Carragher also questions Fernandes' ability to play in the number 10 position, suggesting that he lacks discipline and control in that role.

Both Scholes and Carragher believe that £100m is a fair price for Fernandes, considering his value to the team and his marketability. They think that Manchester United should consider selling him to Al-Hilal, especially if they can get a good deal.